What it means
The CAA records you built don't include the certificate authority that issued your website's current certificate. CAA records tell certificate authorities which of them may issue certificates for your domain, and every authority must check them before issuing.
Why it matters
Once these records are live, your current authority must refuse to issue for your domain. Nothing breaks immediately, but the next renewal fails, often automatically and unnoticed, and your site shows a certificate error when the current certificate expires. Services that renew on your behalf, such as hosting platforms and CDNs, are affected the same way.
How to fix it
- Find out which authority issues your certificate. "Look up my current certificate" in the builder runs the SSL check and fills it in.
- Tick that authority in the builder, or add its CAA identifier, and build the records again.
- Check whether your hosting or CDN uses more than one authority, and include all of them. Cloudflare, for example, issues from several.
- Publish the records only once this finding is gone.
Cloudflare
Cloudflare may issue from Let's Encrypt, Google Trust Services and SSL.com; choose the Cloudflare preset in the builder to include all three.
Check it worked
Build the records again in the CAA builder: the finding should be gone. After publishing, run the SSL check and a DNS lookup for CAA to confirm the records are live, and watch your next renewal.