Fail

There is more than one DKIM record at this selector

The short version

Keep a single DKIM record at the selector.

What it means

There is more than one DKIM record at this selector. This usually happens when a key is replaced by adding the new record without removing the old one.

Why it matters

Receivers expect one key per selector. With two, results vary: some use the first record, some fail the signature, and which record is first can change from one query to the next. Mail may pass DKIM one moment and fail the next.

How to fix it

  1. Find out which key your mail is currently signed with. Your mail provider's DKIM settings show the record it expects.
  2. Delete the other record.
  3. When you rotate keys in future, publish the new key under a new selector, switch signing to it, and remove the old selector after a few days.

Google Workspace

In the Admin console go to Apps, Google Workspace, Gmail, Authenticate email. Generate a 2048-bit key, publish the TXT record it shows at your DNS host, wait for it to appear, then press Start authentication.

Microsoft 365

In the Defender portal open Email authentication settings, then DKIM. Publish the two CNAME records it lists for selector1 and selector2, then turn signing on for the domain.

Check it worked

Run the DKIM record validator with your domain and selector, or the full email check. New keys show up once DNS has updated, usually within an hour. Send yourself a message and look for dkim=pass in its headers to confirm signing works end to end. Only one record should be found at the selector.