Fail

The message body changed after signing

The short version

Find what edits the body after signing (a footer, a mailing list, a forwarder).

What it means

The message body no longer matches the hash in the signature's bh= tag, so something changed the body after it was signed. The headers may still be intact.

Why it matters

A changed body fails DKIM, and if SPF doesn't align either, DMARC fails and the message goes to spam. The usual causes are a mailing list or a security gateway adding a footer or disclaimer, an antivirus tool rewriting links, a forwarder re-encoding the text, or, when you paste a message, line endings or trailing spaces changing on the way. Uploading the original .eml file avoids that last cause.

How to fix it

  1. Upload the original file to the DKIM verifier rather than pasting, to rule out copy-and-paste changes.
  2. If your own gateway adds a footer or rewrites links, make it do so before the DKIM signing step, or have it sign again afterwards.
  3. For mailing lists, have the list sign with its own domain and rewrite the From address, or rely on ARC, which records the original results.
  4. Avoid the l= tag as a workaround: it leaves part of the body unsigned.

Check it worked

Send a new message along the same path, save it as an .eml file and upload it to the DKIM verifier. The body hash should match.