Fail

A DKIM signature has expired

The short version

Shorten the time between signing and delivery, or lengthen the signature's x= lifetime.

What it means

The signature carries an expiry time in its x= tag, and that time has passed. The detail gives the expiry. Receivers treat an expired signature as failed.

Why it matters

Signatures with a short expiry are sometimes used on purpose, so an old message can't be replayed later, but an expiry that is too short breaks mail that waits in a queue or is checked a day later. A server clock that is wrong produces the same effect. Once the signature has expired, DKIM no longer helps DMARC pass for that message.

How to fix it

  1. Check the sending server's time and time zone; a clock set years ahead or behind gives odd t= and x= values.
  2. In the signing software, raise the signature lifetime to at least a few days, or turn the expiry off: x= is optional.
  3. If you are checking an old message on purpose, an expired signature is expected and nothing needs fixing.

Check it worked

Send a new message, save it and upload it to the DKIM verifier straight away. The signing and expiry times should be sensible and the signature should verify.