Fail

The DKIM key for a signature isn't in DNS

The short version

Publish the selector's public key at <selector>._domainkey.<domain>.

What it means

The message carries a DKIM signature, but there is no key at the DNS name it points to: <selector>._domainkey.<domain>, built from the signature's s= and d= tags. The detail names the signing domain and selector. A revoked key (an empty p=) counts here too.

Why it matters

Receivers can't check a signature without its key, so the signature fails and DKIM can't help DMARC pass. This usually happens when a key was removed or rotated before all mail stopped using it, when a new sending service was set up but its DNS records were never published, or when the selector was typed differently in DNS.

How to fix it

  1. Note the selector and domain in the result.
  2. In the sending service's settings, find the DKIM records it asks you to publish. They are often CNAME records named like s1._domainkey.
  3. Publish exactly that name at your DNS host, with the value the service gives you.
  4. If the key was retired on purpose, switch the service to the new selector, or keep the old key published for a few days while mail in transit is delivered.

Check it worked

Check the key with the DKIM record validator, then send a new message, save it and verify it in the DKIM verifier. The signature should pass.