Warning

Your nameservers serve different DNSSEC keys

The short version

Make sure every nameserver serves the same signed zone; one may be out of date.

What it means

Your nameservers serve different sets of DNSSEC keys. Resolvers that ask one server see one set; resolvers that ask another see a different one.

Why it matters

Signatures made with a key that one server doesn't serve fail on that server, so validation fails at random for some visitors. It usually means one server stopped receiving updates, or two providers sign the same zone separately.

How to fix it

  1. Compare the key tags per server in the key table to find the odd one out.
  2. Check that zone transfers to that server work and that it serves the latest serial.
  3. If two providers serve the zone, use their multi-signer setup or keep only one signer.
  4. Remove a server that can't be brought up to date.

Check it worked

Run the DNSSEC and nameserver check again. Every server should list the same key tags.